Contracts with third parties such as sub-contractors
6.2 Terms of Business
Following initial discussions with a prospective landlord, the agent sets out the terms, in writing; the principal (more commonly called the landlord in the letting situation) accepts, they both sign and the contract comes into existence. It is of paramount importance that the agent does nothing which may constitute a commencement of his service until the landlord has signed the agreement and given authorisation to proceed.
Unfortunately the ‘law of agency’ is not one set of statutory regulations. The ‘law’ has developed over many centuries as common law, statute, case law and so on. This whole subject is full of difficulty and ‘grey’ areas. This means that any person who holds himself out as an agent for a principal would be taking huge risks if the terms of that agency are not clearly understood and legally compliant. Any agent who acts beyond that authority is running significant risks.
It follows therefore that an agent should aim to produce a ‘watertight’ agreement. The agreement must not only accurately reflect the terms agreed by the parties, but it must also be consistent with what is customary practice for the business concerned (The RICS code of practice for lettings and management is a good starting point). The agreement must also be ‘personal’ to the individual principal’s circumstances and instructions and it must be current. The problem in most busy agency offices is that a ‘standard’ agreement is produced and used in every case without thinking. The standard agreement may be out of date (staff may not be doing things that way anymore) or it may not cover some particular aspect of that client’s property or instructions.
6.2.1 General Principles
The moment a landlord says “go ahead”, in other words when an agent offers to carry out services for a landlord and the landlord either expressly or by implication says “okay”, the agreement is created. The agreement will continue until it is expressly cancelled by the parties or until the services have been concluded. This means that if the arrangement was for a tenant find, the agreement will end as soon as the tenancy has commenced. Where an agent is instructed to manage a property the agreement will run as long as the parties have agreed or until the end of the tenancy, unless cancelled earlier. Unless expressly stated, the agent has no authority to act thereafter nor is the agent liable for any events occurring after that date (unless they arise from some earlier act or omission by the agent).
An agency agreement may be implied by the conduct of the parties and it may also be subsequently ratified after the performance of the event. Ratification is not always a straightforward matter, but it may be expressed or implied, i.e. the landlord accepting rent or taking no action to evict a tenant would be deemed to have ratified the arrangement.
An agency agreement may also be created by the extension of an existing relationship. It is not unusual for an agent to be engaged during the pre-let refurbishment of a property; in which case the agency agreement can start long before finding a tenant has commenced.
During the engagement/management period the landlord will be liable for all of the agent’s actions in the day to day management of the property. This could be rent collection, dealing with repairs and disputes. The extent of the agent’s authority will depend upon what the parties have agreed, express instructions given by the landlord, the law or authority implied by the conduct of the parties plus a duty of care.
6.2.2 Drafting/sourcing Term of Business
Agents who are members of a professional body may be required to use terms of business that comply with that organisation’s guidance. Templates are made available by them. Templates can also be purchased or drafted by a legal advisor.
Agent’s Terms of Business are a critical legal document in a letting business. A well drafted agreement assists both parties; the scope of the service provided will be clear from the outset and disputes can usually be resolved by reference to the contractual position of the parties. It is not uncommon for an agent to obtain copies of competitors’ terms and use these as a base for drafting. Whilst this may be a good starting point there is no guarantee that other agreements are correct in law, or that those terms will accurately reflect the actual service to be provided.
It is essential that any agreement is in plain English, is fair and accurately reflects the agency’s current practice or any particular matters agreed with an individual landlord. Variables such as fees are best shown as separate attachments.
The Consumer Rights Act 2015 may apply. Essentially, this legislation is there to ensure the terms are fair and balanced. The legislation requires businesses to use terms which are not too technical, to make the interpretation simple. The contract should not seek to permit the agent to do or not do something which the law does not permit. Similarly, clauses which seek to waive the agent’s liability may not be regarded as fair. Declarations which say that the client has read and understood the contract are regarded as unenforceable, because if a client cannot understand a contract, stating that he does will add nothing to the contract. The legislation requires the agent to give the client adequate time to read and reflect before signing and accepting the services offered and in some cases a ‘cooling off’ period.
Drafting the terms of business is an ongoing process. Agents should review the terms at least annually to ensure that the current day to day working practice is reflected in the terms.
6.2.3 Fees and charges
Agents usually base management fees as a percentage of the rent collected, plus separate costs for setting up, agreement fee, inventory fee etc. Clarity is needed as to whether the management fee is payable on ‘rents due’ or ‘rents collected’. The latter means that charges only apply if the tenant pays the rent, yet the agent will still be providing a management service throughout the period of non-payment. Also ensure it clarifies when the fees are payable. Some agents will collect the fee monthly from the rent collected and others will charge the whole fee for the agreed tenancy up front.
An agent should always think about extra cost that can come along in day to day management. Who pays the cost for attending court or inspecting an empty property? Who pays for administration and time sourcing and arranging the delivery of a new appliance?
Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 agents’ fees for both their landlord and tenant clients must be displayed in a place likely to be seen in their office premises and on any website (if any). See Chapter 8 later for more details. The fees quoted must also be inclusive of VAT.
The terms of business require clarity on matters such as minimum charges and what fees will be payable on the cancellation of the agreement. Is the fee for a sole agency and do charges apply if the landlord lets via another agency? The agent needs to protect his business against a landlord who withdraws early, but severely penalising such a landlord is not fair.
6.2.4 Variation
Once signed the parties cannot make changes (including fees) to the terms of business without consent. A provision to change the terms upon reasonable notice should be included, but that will give the landlord the opportunity to say no and withdraw instructions. Clearly it is not expedient to sign a new agreement every time fees are changed. This can be done by separate letter or notice, giving the landlord the opportunity to accept or decline (within a reasonable time limit). It is possible to build in a fee structure that enables increased fees by a set criteria. Where variations are agreed verbally or by practice, they should be recorded as a variation to the original terms and signed by all parties.
6.2.5 Termination
A landlord may revoke his agent’s authority at any time either verbally or in writing. Some agents seek to make termination difficult, but it is questionable whether penalty type clauses are enforceable. In view of the ‘close’ relationship between an agent and a principal it is better to end it sooner where the parties are not satisfied with the arrangements or working well together. If the client can prove that the service is unsatisfactory it is unlikely that a court would hold a landlord to the agreement.
The agent should require a reasonable notice period and can make a minimum fee payable so as to avoid early termination. Many agents will have a minimum fee equivalent to cover six months’ management. This will reduce the risk of a landlord cancelling his instructions immediately the first tenant has taken possession.
The agent should reserve the right to terminate the contract without notice where the landlord is unwilling to comply with statutory obligations.
An agency agreement will terminate immediately upon the principal’s death. The principal’s estate is not bound by anything the agent does post death of the client even if the agent is not immediately aware of the death of the client. This will also apply if the property is sold as the landlord cannot manage the property, neither can the agent without instruction from the new owner.
6.2.6 Agency by Estoppel
Estoppel is a legal term, meaning that a person is precluded from denying the truth of a statement of fact previously asserted. This means that where one person has acted so as to lead another person to believe he has authorised a third party to act on his behalf, and that person, believing this, enters into a transaction within the scope of the authority, the first person is estopped from denying the agency. The fact that the agent may not have had express authority is immaterial. For instance, a tenant may be told by a landlord that he should ‘contact the agent’ regarding the defective heating. If the agent arranges a repair the landlord cannot claim that he is not bound by what the agent has done and he will be liable for the cost of the repair.
Good employment practice is essential for any agency. It requires production of clear policies and rules and procedures for all staff. These policies include health and safety, helping employees understand their legal obligations and what their employer expects of them and how they should carry out certain activities. They also advise employees of the rules and rewards available to them.
6.2.7 Cancellation Of Consumer Contracts
Under the Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, in force from the 13 June 2014, agents taking on consumer landlords must follow new rules.
Distance and off premises contracts have an automatic right to cancel within 14 days of agreeing the contract. Also, within that 14 day period, the agent is not allowed to do any work for the landlord without the landlords express consent. Clearly most landlords will not want the agent to wait 14 days before starting arranging EPC and advertising etc so express consent is likely to become the norm. If any work is done within the 14 days cancellation without following this process, then no charges are payable by the consumer.
Firstly consumer landlord contracts will fall into one of three basic categories. Distance contracts (concluded without meeting), off premises contracts (basically those agreed from a home visit) and on premises contracts (those where the consumer comes to your premises and concludes the contract. For letting agents most contracts will probably be distance or off premises contracts. While it is accepted that some landlord will not be consumers, it may prove too tricky to identify the difference and therefore granting the same right to all may be a way of simplifying the business.
In all three contract situations there is “prescribed information” (from the schedules at the back of the regulations) that has to be given to the consumer. There is a longer list for distance and off premises and, again, to simply things this longer list could be used for all consumers regardless of which type of contract they have. Failure to give this information could allow a consumer to cancel in anything up to twelve months and two weeks without having to pay anything!
Additionally, for distance and off premises contracts it is a legal requirement to include information about the consumer’s right to cancel and a cancellation notice they can complete and return if they wish to exercise their right to cancel.
The regulations also prohibit “additional charges” without the express consent of the consumer. This would obviously apply to making a charge not agreed at the point of creating the contract but could also be applied to increasing the amount charged. It is also not clear if a term in the contract allowing the agent to increase charges on a certain notice period would be consider to be express consent.
The regulations also require consumers to be able to contact the trader on a basic rate phone number in order to seek assistance in their contractual relationship.
Breach of these regulations carries unlimited fines.
6.3 Employment contracts
As any business starts to expand there comes a point where it is necessary to take on extra staff. Permanent employees will work on a full-time or part-time basis and must by law have a written statement of their main terms of employment. The following responsibilities apply in all cases: